Jim R.
2009-02-04 17:46:08 UTC
Not that anybody cares except me, but I culled this summary over a
period of years, mostly from Rob Stone's excellent book "Laurel or
Hardy: The solo films of Stan Laurel and Oliver 'Babe' Hardy," plus
some later rediscoveries after his book was published in 1996.
The first number in each group is the number of films that are known
to survive. The second number is the number of films that Oliver or
Stan is known to have appeared in. (Oliver first because his film
career started earlier.) Years are production years.
The number that have been released on home video, and, in particular,
DVD, is a completely different matter!
Disclaimer: Any errors below are due to gremlins, and are not my
fault.
OLIVER HARDY WITHOUT STAN LAUREL (1914-50, mostly through 1926):
107 of 276 films total
4 of 54 split reelers
20 of 89 one-reelers
76 of 121 two-reelers
7 of 12 full-length feature films
Lubin (1914-5): 7 of 65
4 of 54 split reelers
3 of 11 one-reelers
Edison (1915): 5 of 5 (all one-reelers)
Wharton Bros. (1915): 2 of 5
1 of 4 serial chapters
1 of 1 full length feature film ("The Lottery Man")
"New York Miscellaneous" (1915): 2 of 5 (all one-reelers)
Vim (1915-7): 8 of 66 (all one-reelers)
"Plump and Runt," with Billy Ruge: 7 of 35
King Bee (1917-8): 16 of 27
with Billy West: 15 of 26
Universal/L-KO (1918): 4 of 9
Vitagraph (1919-23): 24 of 48
with Jimmy Aubrey: 6 of 26
with Larry Semon: 18 of 20
full-length feature films: 0 of 2
Larry Semon independents (1924-5): 4 of 6
full-length feature films: 2 of 4
Arrow (1924-5): 7 of 7
with Bobby Ray: 4 of 4
with Billy West: 3 of 3
Fox (1924-5): 1 of 3
full-length feature film: 0 of 1 ("The Gentle Cyclone," with Buck
Jones)
Mack Sennett (1926): 1 of 1 ("Crazy to Act")
Hal Roach (1925-39): 23 of 26
1 of 1 one-reeler ("Yes Yes Nanette")
with Charley Chase: 6 of 6
Stan Laurel collaborations: 7 of 8
full-length feature films: 2 of 2 (one sound: "Zenobia")
Other later films (1938-50): 3 of 3
1 of 1 one-reeler ("Hollywood Handicap")
2 of 2 full-length feature films
STAN LAUREL WITHOUT OLIVER HARDY (1917-27):
49 (+6) of 63 films total
(Note: the pluses are for films that have only partially survived.
Some have survived more than others.)
16 of 20 one-reelers
26 (+6) of 42 two-reelers
1 of 1 three-reeler
And...
15 (+1) of 18 films that he worked on for a week or more, but did not
appear in
(all at Hal Roach Studios, 1925-6)
(I didn't write down the number of one-reelers!)
Bernstein (1917): (pt.) of 1 ("Nuts in May")
Universal (1917): 0 of 4
0 of 2 one-reelers
Rolin (1918): 3 of 5 (all one-reelers)
Vitagraph (1918): 3 of 3 (with Larry Semon)
Amalgamated (Anderson) (1922-3): 5 (+2) of 7
1 of 1 three-reeler ("Mud and Sand")
Plus "The Lucky Dog" (1921)
Hal Roach (1) (1923-4): 22 (+2) of 25
13 of 13 one-reelers
Joe Rock (1924-5): 10 (+1) of 12
Hal Roach (2) (1925-7): 6 of 6
That's the lot. All but one of the surviving Stan Laurel solos have
been released on DVD by one source or another. The sole exception is
the surviving second reel of "When Knights Were Cold," his last film
for G. M. "Broncho Billy" Anderson, produced in early 1923.
period of years, mostly from Rob Stone's excellent book "Laurel or
Hardy: The solo films of Stan Laurel and Oliver 'Babe' Hardy," plus
some later rediscoveries after his book was published in 1996.
The first number in each group is the number of films that are known
to survive. The second number is the number of films that Oliver or
Stan is known to have appeared in. (Oliver first because his film
career started earlier.) Years are production years.
The number that have been released on home video, and, in particular,
DVD, is a completely different matter!
Disclaimer: Any errors below are due to gremlins, and are not my
fault.
OLIVER HARDY WITHOUT STAN LAUREL (1914-50, mostly through 1926):
107 of 276 films total
4 of 54 split reelers
20 of 89 one-reelers
76 of 121 two-reelers
7 of 12 full-length feature films
Lubin (1914-5): 7 of 65
4 of 54 split reelers
3 of 11 one-reelers
Edison (1915): 5 of 5 (all one-reelers)
Wharton Bros. (1915): 2 of 5
1 of 4 serial chapters
1 of 1 full length feature film ("The Lottery Man")
"New York Miscellaneous" (1915): 2 of 5 (all one-reelers)
Vim (1915-7): 8 of 66 (all one-reelers)
"Plump and Runt," with Billy Ruge: 7 of 35
King Bee (1917-8): 16 of 27
with Billy West: 15 of 26
Universal/L-KO (1918): 4 of 9
Vitagraph (1919-23): 24 of 48
with Jimmy Aubrey: 6 of 26
with Larry Semon: 18 of 20
full-length feature films: 0 of 2
Larry Semon independents (1924-5): 4 of 6
full-length feature films: 2 of 4
Arrow (1924-5): 7 of 7
with Bobby Ray: 4 of 4
with Billy West: 3 of 3
Fox (1924-5): 1 of 3
full-length feature film: 0 of 1 ("The Gentle Cyclone," with Buck
Jones)
Mack Sennett (1926): 1 of 1 ("Crazy to Act")
Hal Roach (1925-39): 23 of 26
1 of 1 one-reeler ("Yes Yes Nanette")
with Charley Chase: 6 of 6
Stan Laurel collaborations: 7 of 8
full-length feature films: 2 of 2 (one sound: "Zenobia")
Other later films (1938-50): 3 of 3
1 of 1 one-reeler ("Hollywood Handicap")
2 of 2 full-length feature films
STAN LAUREL WITHOUT OLIVER HARDY (1917-27):
49 (+6) of 63 films total
(Note: the pluses are for films that have only partially survived.
Some have survived more than others.)
16 of 20 one-reelers
26 (+6) of 42 two-reelers
1 of 1 three-reeler
And...
15 (+1) of 18 films that he worked on for a week or more, but did not
appear in
(all at Hal Roach Studios, 1925-6)
(I didn't write down the number of one-reelers!)
Bernstein (1917): (pt.) of 1 ("Nuts in May")
Universal (1917): 0 of 4
0 of 2 one-reelers
Rolin (1918): 3 of 5 (all one-reelers)
Vitagraph (1918): 3 of 3 (with Larry Semon)
Amalgamated (Anderson) (1922-3): 5 (+2) of 7
1 of 1 three-reeler ("Mud and Sand")
Plus "The Lucky Dog" (1921)
Hal Roach (1) (1923-4): 22 (+2) of 25
13 of 13 one-reelers
Joe Rock (1924-5): 10 (+1) of 12
Hal Roach (2) (1925-7): 6 of 6
That's the lot. All but one of the surviving Stan Laurel solos have
been released on DVD by one source or another. The sole exception is
the surviving second reel of "When Knights Were Cold," his last film
for G. M. "Broncho Billy" Anderson, produced in early 1923.